
There is one (only one!) downside to being an iSkeptic: I can't report on the iPhone from direct PERSONAL experience.
What I wrote in my blog a week ago is STILL true: "I haven't touched the iPhone yet. I haven't sniffed it, stroked it, slipped it in my pocket, or tried to download anything over its very slow Internet connection. I also haven't tried to thumb-type yet on its slippery little glass face."
Why? Because, unlike all the iPhone faddists, I haven't plunked down hundreds of dollars for an untested unproven iDevice. I'm not drinking spiked Koolaid either.
Luckily for us, all those who bought the iPhone, like my buddy Steve Jones, can now answer our questions.
Here are my Top Ten:
1) What about, uh, just making a simple phone call?
Is it true that the iPhone takes six steps to make a phone call?
How long will that take to get on your nerves? Two days? Three?
Is it true that the required AT&T partnership forces you to use one of the most notoriously bad networks in the country?
Do makeup and fingerprints smear all over the device screen?
2) How about typing in a phone number or a note-to-self?
Call me "so last century" – but I save ideas in text form.
Can you type at all on the non-tactile "keys"?
I hear that period and commas require a 2nd screen. Is that one of those deceptive "urban legends"?
And I also hear that you can't copy or paste anything while you type. Tell me it ain't so!
3) Is it true that iPhones can't handle instant messaging?
Not even a little bit?
4) Is it true that non-Apple headphones need a special adapter?
All because Apple deliberately recessed the jack? And what about stereo Bluetooth headsets – is it true they won't work with iPhones?
5) Is it true the iPhone can't be used as a modem for your laptop?
How many of us have been using our internet capable phones (and the expensive internet access we pay for) as a modem for laptop surfing – in airports, or cars or wherever we like? Is it true that this basic ability was left off the iPhone?
6) Is it true that iPhone can't handle Flash?
How can it be state-of-the-art web-browsing without flash web annimation? Has anyone made a list of how many valuable sites instantly became unavailable? I just wrote a revew of the Transformer movie on another blog -- but often you can't even see high graphic sites like the official movie page without flash!
7) Games... there just aren't any, right?
Doesn't Apple claim they are all about "fun"? Is there a date when games might appear for the iPhone?
How come current iTunes games aren't usable on iPhones? Why are users stuck with only web-based entertainment (using the battery eating web connection)?
8) Is it true that you can't download songs directly from iTunes to your iPhone
Why can't you hear and buy new music directly -- the way I can download from Yahoo Music Unlimited onto my Sansa Connect?
Isn't syncing music completely out-dated?
And what about the iPhone not having a removable storage card – isn't that standard on every device you already have?
9) Can you share with me the implications of not having a removable battery?
What happens on a trip, or when you are in a hurry, or when you have a long day with lots of calling? Does it mean that your charger now comes standard, inside your briefcase? At least until you have charged the iPhone 300 or 400 times and that battery dies. What are you planning to do then – live without the phone while it makes a trip to the factory, or do what Apple expects…. Buy their next magic device?
And now for our final question:
10) First look at this equation: $500 or $600 + ($60/month) x 24 months + taxes = $2200.
Then tell me this: Is the iPhone really worth two grand for two years?!
On the basics of phoning and simple usefulness, is it even AS GOOD as what you are already using?
You think I'm techno-obsessed? You haven't seen my Daddy!
This first discovery was what started me thinking that an article like this would be useful to those of you on the fence. I have accumulated more than 8 iPods over the years and have invested in quite a few accessories along the way. I hadn't really thought about trying the iPhone with these until I swapped it in for a old iPod Mini I had hooked up to a pair of standalone speakers. At first, the I got a message on the screen complaining that the device was "not made to work with the iPhone" and that it suggested turning off the phone while it was docked to reduce interference (i.e. its cell radio interfering with device's own electronics including speakers, FM transmitters, etc.).
I had recently purchased a Sansa Connect (which I love) and was really jazzed about its external speaker, not because the sound was particularly impressive but because I didn't always have to wear headphones to enjoy my music. Well, the iPhone has support for a true speakerphone so of course you can "blast" your tunes in the same way. This is actually less useful for enjoying music but is incredibly handy for sharing videos with your friends, whether through the iPod interface or directly from YouTube. It may not sound like much, but this is the first iPod to have a speaker at all and it seems so obvious now that I've used it.
I've had mobile phones with WiFi support before but never used that feature for several reasons. First, wifi radios suck battery life if left on (this one may too of course, but I haven't seen any indication or reports yet). Second, it was always too painful to find & connect to wireless networks - and this is where Apple hit a home run. Whenever you are in range of a known or friendly (i.e. open) WiFi signal, the phone can switch over from the slower EDGE cell network so that you can continue your online activities at much more familiar speeds. This works really well in my house and office especially and I already find myself using the Net on my phone more than I thought I would.
Its cool enough that the supplied headphones provide a way to accept calls while listening to music and to resume after the call ends - but this is a feature that has appeared previously with other phones. I do have to say that using two earbuds for phone calls is actually preferable than a single ear solution, even with the wires. But the killer feature is having the same control on the headphone wire also integrate with the onboard iPod. For example, squeezing the control once pauses or resume the current song and pressing twice will advance to the next song. Very handy. Makes me wonder if I should give it up in favor of a new Bluetooth headset or opt for a better set of iPhone-compatible buds.

RSS



Update on iPod accessories
I don't necessarily recommend FM transmitters as a good audio solution but if you don't have a direct link option to your car's in-dash radio or use the wacky cassette tape adapter, its not a terrible alternative.
So the big story here is that you are likely to be pleasantly surprised to find many of your legacy iPod accessories are compatible with your iPhone - and that is a huge relief if, like me, you were concerned about having to spend even more money to add the iPhone to your already complicated (and expensive) gadget world.
Early Adopter Extraordinaire!